Gario's Pizza Villa

Nestled in the heart of Montgomery, Illinois, Gario's Pizza Villa stands as a beloved destination for pizza lovers and fans of authentic Italian flavors. Specializing in old-school tavern-style pizza, this local gem offers an inviting atmosphere paired with a menu that promises to satisfy even the most discerning cravings.

The true star of Gario's menu is undoubtedly their pizza. From the classic Thin Crust Cheese Pizza and the indulgent Everything Pizza to fan favorites like the Half Cheese Half Sausage Pizza and the savory Sausage Half Black Olive Pizza, each bite bursts with a perfect balance of tangy sauce, melted cheese, and just the right amount of toppings. Whether you crave the simplicity of their Black Olives Pizza or the hearty goodness of the Sausage Cheese Pizza, every slice is crafted with a devotion to quality and flavor that shines through.

But Gario’s experience extends beyond the pizza pie. Dishes such as crispy Fried Green Beans and surprisingly addictive Nachos add variety and offer something special for those wanting more than just the traditional Italian fare. And for a sweet finish, their Cup Cakes provide a delightful treat that rounds out the meal perfectly. Patrons can also enjoy a refreshing Corona, enhancing the laid-back, family-friendly vibe that Gario's has famously cultivated over the years.

Walking into Gario’s feels like stepping back into a cherished memory for many locals. The clean, welcoming space offers not only delicious food but also a nostalgic ambiance—with classic arcade games like skee ball and racing machines adding an old-school charm that keeps guests entertained between bites. This combination of mouth-watering food and warm atmosphere has made Gario’s a fixture for families and friends to connect over great meals and good times.

Longtime patrons, such as Vanessa Claudio, praise the restaurant for consistently delivering excellent pizza and helpful service, calling it "never a let down." Others, like David Scott, appreciate the faithful Chicago thin crust style and the nostalgic vibe, highlighting the spot as a perfect blend of quality and comfort. Newcomers like Jireh Tyler are quickly converted by the friendly staff and outstanding flavor, often returning for more. For many, the real magic is in the way Gario's makes its guests feel—whether it’s a familiar visit or a first bite.

Whether you’re ordering delivery, stopping in for takeout, or enjoying a meal in-house, Gario’s Pizza Villa stands out as a beacon of authentic, heartfelt pizza craftsmanship. It’s a place where every slice tells a story, and every visit leaves you looking forward to the next. If you find yourself in Montgomery craving that perfect slice or a flavorful meal that feels like home, Gario's Pizza Villa is unequivocally the place to be.